Metropolis Reality Forums - The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost

Sponsored by: The Fans!

Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register.
Nov 22^nd, 2024, 9:17pm

Upcoming Premiere Dates:
Survivor 23, Season premiere
Thursday, September 14 (8:00-9:30 PM, ET/PT) on CBS

Metropolis Reality Forums Ť The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost ť

   Metropolis Reality Forums
   Other Television Shows
   Other Television Shows (Moderators: lakelady, yesteach, MediaScribe, Bumper, Isle_be_back)
   The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost

Previous topic | New Topic | Next topic »

Pages: 1

Add Poll

Notify of replies

Send Topic

Author

Topic: The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost (Read 297 times)

Insane 4 Survivor
Moderator
ForumsNet Member

My New Home

Gender:

Posts: 4438

The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost
« on: May 20^th, 2005, 10:49am »

Quote

Modify

The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost
by David Bloomberg -- 05/20/2005

Tana looked great heading into the final round. But then, the Apprenticeship that she thought she had wrapped up was instead crumpled up and thrown into the garbage can. What happened? Why did Tana lose?

Tana seemed to have the Apprenticeship in the bag right up until the final task. Then she blew it all away. What happened to cause such a huge turnaround? Was it something she did or something her opponent did? Why did Tana lose?

Weve waited two weeks to find out who would win, now we analyze the final results. But the way we do it hasnt changed we still look back at What Apprentice 3 Applicants Should Have Learned to see what Tana did right and where she went so very, very wrong.

The first rule is to show leadership. Tana did a good job of this throughout the course of the show, being Project Manager three times and taking on a leadership type of role even when she wasnt officially in charge. Overall, her record as a Project Manager was two wins and one loss not bad, though Kendra beat her by going three-for-three.

One thing she did in leading her group was to create a good atmosphere. Tana always showed her personality, which had been fun-loving and excited.

Until the final task.

Tana went into the final task with three of the most hot-headed contestants, two of whom were virtually worthless (Chris was the only one with redeeming qualities). The problem is that leaders are often saddled with employees they dont necessarily like and couldnt pick. In fact, in the real world, managers quite often are promoted or transferred into areas where the employees are already there; rarely does a person get to handpick their entire staff. Good leaders can make the best of what theyve got.

Tana didnt do that. Instead, she griped about her staff to everybody who would listen. This is not a sign of good management. Furthermore, after all her talk about how she thought they were horrible, she didnt even keep tabs on them for some of the most important tasks, such as when she allowed Kristen to do the printed program job all by herself which of course ended in disaster.

So really, her failure here was twofold. First, she did not treat her employees well. Second, she knew she had bad workers but failed to properly manage them. Its not looking good when you have two strikes just from the first rule!

The second rule says to stay cool under fire. Throughout Tanas time on the show, she did one of the best jobs in this area even including the final task. For example, while her answer to the governors aide about him sitting and waiting was probably not the best one, some people would have freaked out with that and all the other pressure points being put upon them. Tana didnt. She handled all of the various crises by simply dealing with them one at a time.

Tana showed that she followed the third rule, having a backbone, by the way she stood up for herself and her ideas throughout the process. Then, in the final live Boardroom, she really gave her backbone a workout. Unfortunately, I dont think it came off quite the way she wanted it to. She was raising her voice and making sure she was heard when she wanted to defend herself or make a point. But she was also pointing her finger a lot and even pumped her fist in the air at one point!

I suspect Tana was acting this way because she knew she had nothing to lose. Might as well go in and be fierce and try to steal the thing from Kendra, right? Well, maybe. But it didnt impress any viewer Ive talked to since then, and it didnt impress Donald Trump either, who was quoted in an AP news story as saying, I thought it was a little much. I don't mind aggression in men or women, but I found it to be a little obnoxious. I didn't love it.

The fourth rule has no bearing on Tanas loss, so lets skip to the fifth. That rule says to play well with others and stay professional. Weve already detailed how Tana dealt poorly with her staff on the final task, but there is another aspect to staying professional that we should address.

In the final live Boardroom, Ive already mentioned how Tana was acting. Even the answers she gave when she wasnt shouting or whooping it up were certainly not the best ever. Meanwhile, Kendra gave polished answers that clearly and concisely conveyed the proper information and showed that she could function in a true business environment. I have to tell you, if I saw somebody behaving the way Tana was in a work meeting, Id have left and wondered, What the hell was that all about and who is she? Kendra, however, would have given me no such pause.

The sixth rule says to focus on the long-term. Tana had been doing okay at this throughout most of the competition, but forgot all about it at the end. She was so focused on the task that she ignored one of the main components that she should have known Trump would be studying how she behaved and managed. Weve already dealt with those two topics, but I just want to reiterate here that these were failures on multiple levels. The final challenge is not so much a competition to see who wins by doing it better, its a test to see how you work. Even though the NYC 2012 event went off fine, Tana still failed that test.

Throughout her time on the show, George noted that Tana had tremendous ideas and creativity in other words, she followed the seventh rule of thinking outside the box. The final challenge did not really give her much opportunity to be creative, since all the events and attendees were set up ahead of time. Her earlier performance could have helped Trump decide at the end if things had been more even, but, well, they werent.

Eighth is to not be one-dimensional. I think Carolyn said it best in the finale when she pointed out that Tana is a great salesperson. Carolyn chooses her words wisely, and she meant exactly what she said that is one area where Tana did a great job. But as the rule specifically notes, Trump is not looking for a salesperson. As mentioned above, George pointed out that Tana had great ideas. The rule also notes, [Trump] isnt looking for an idea person.

Trump is looking for somebody who is multitalented, and one of those talents must be leadership, as we referred to earlier.

Finally, we arrive at the rule that says contestants should use common sense. For many of the reasons outlined above, Tana blew it here as well:

It defies common sense to ask if she can trade team members after they have been given to her.
It defies common sense to call your team members The Three Stooges to one of the judges (Carolyn).
It defies common sense to talk about your team members negatively to other people around you, especially when one of those team members is nearby.
It defies common sense to be on a show where cameras follow you everywhere and make repeated disparaging remarks about the people who worked with you when those remarks and their reaction to them will play into the decision of whether or not you win.
Somewhere along the line, Tana forgot where she was and what her goal should have been. She became so focused on the fact that she had been saddled with three difficult personalities that she lost sight of the prize.

Tana started out well but her stock dropped precipitously in the final weeks. Kendra started off slow but ended with a grand flourish. Tana needed a solid performance in the final challenge to win. It didnt need to be great she had been great for most of the season. She just needed to be solid. But she wasnt. She was unprofessional (both in dealing with her employees and in her behavior on the live show) and, more importantly, she was a horrible leader. That is why Tana lost.

IP Logged

"I feel sorry for people who don't drink. When they wake up in the morning, that's as good as they're going to feel all day."
Frank Sinatra

Superchic7777
ForumsNet Member

Little Miss Know-It-All

Gender:

Posts: 861

Re: The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost
« Reply #1 on: May 20^th, 2005, 3:03pm »

Quote

Modify

That's actually a very good question. I believe she lost because Trump couldn't get past how much her team hated her.

IP Logged

Big Brother 6 is finally here!!!!

Congratulations to Kelly and Alec, winners of Dancing With The Stars!

CallMeRob
You Bet Your ASS Team
ForumsNet Member

Gender:

Posts: 6754

Re: The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost
« Reply #2 on: May 20^th, 2005, 3:53pm »

Quote

Modify

You know why? Coz she should and Kendra should win.

IP Logged

Please give my blog, daily clicks!
http://inghinyero.blogspot.com
And my reality show overload blog:
http://inghinyero-reality.blogspot.com

Superchic7777
ForumsNet Member

Little Miss Know-It-All

Gender:

Posts: 861

Re: The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost
« Reply #3 on: May 20^th, 2005, 6:43pm »

Quote

Modify

I don't think Tana should have said she had a disadvantage over Kendra, because that's a slight sign of weakness, just like Kendra's crying.

IP Logged

Big Brother 6 is finally here!!!!

Congratulations to Kelly and Alec, winners of Dancing With The Stars!

Lucky
ForumsNet Member

Catch A Falling Star

Gender:

Posts: 2271

Re: The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost
« Reply #4 on: May 21^st, 2005, 12:58pm »

Quote

Modify

Tana lost because she was negative about her team. If she had just worked with what she had an supervised more she probably would have won.

IP Logged

TAR All-Stars: Dustin/Kandice, Charla/Mirna & Oswald/Danny

Dixie
ForumsNet Member

Vizsla Lover

Gender:

Posts: 659

Re: The Apprentice 3: Why Tana Lost
« Reply #5 on: May 21^st, 2005, 9:34pm »

Quote

Modify

I think the main reason Tana lost is because she doesn't have a college degree. Go back and look at all the shows since the first Apprentice. trump LOVES and education above all else.

I work in this type of environment and I can tell you, Kendra wouldn't last 5 minutes.

IP Logged

If you can't be a good example -- then you'll just have to be a horrible warning.

Pages: 1

Add Poll

Notify of replies

Send Topic


Previous topic \| New Topic \| Next topic »